G 0004/95 (Representation) of 19.2.1996

European Case Law Identifier: ECLI:EP:BA:1996:G000495.19960219
Date of decision: 19 February 1996
Case number: G 0004/95
Referral: T 0803/93
Application number: 85304219.0
IPC class: G07G 1/06
Language of proceedings: EN
Distribution: A
Download and more information:
Decision text in EN (PDF, 1.012M)
Documentation of the appeal procedure can be found in the Register
Bibliographic information is available in: EN
Versions: OJ | Published
Title of application: Apparatus and method for reducing theft from a store
Applicant name: Bogasky, John J.
Opponent name: Sensormatic Electronics Corp.
Board: EBA
Headnote: I. During oral proceedings under Article 116 EPC in the context of opposition or opposition appeal proceedings, a person accompanying the professional representative of a party may be allowed to make oral submissions on specific legal or technical issues on behalf of that party, otherwise than under Article 117 EPC, in addition to the complete presentation of the party's case by the professional representative.
II. (a) Such oral submissions cannot be made as a matter of right, but only with the permission of and under the discretion of the EPO.
(b) The following main criteria should be considered by the EPO when exercising its discretion to allow the making of oral submissions by an accompanying person in opposition or opposition appeal proceedings:
(i) The professional representative should request permission for such oral submissions to be made. The request should state the name and qualifications of the accompanying person, and should specify the subject- matter of the proposed oral submissions.
(ii) The request should be made sufficiently in advance of the oral proceedings so that all opposing parties are able properly to prepare themselves in relation to the proposed oral submissions.
(iii) A request which is made shortly before or at the oral proceedings should in the absence of exceptional circumstances be refused, unless each opposing party agrees to the making of the oral submissions requested.
(iv) The EPO should be satisfied that oral submissions by an accompanying person are made under the continuing responsibility and control of the professional representative.
(c) No special criteria apply to the making of oral submissions by qualified patent lawyers of countries which are not Contracting States to the EPC.
Relevant legal provisions:
European Patent Convention 1973 Art 116
European Patent Convention 1973 Art 117
European Patent Convention 1973 Art 133
European Patent Convention 1973 Art 134
Keywords: Oral submissions by an accompanying person in opposition or opposition appeal proceedings


Cited decisions:
Citing decisions:
G 0002/12
G 0002/13
J 0001/04
R 0003/08
R 0010/10
R 0022/10
R 0012/12
T 0085/93
T 0803/93
T 1077/93
T 1082/93
T 0097/94
T 0334/94
T 0151/95
T 0840/95
T 0941/95
T 0476/96
T 0212/97
T 0502/97
T 0633/97
T 0899/97
T 1180/97
T 0005/98
T 0144/98
T 0241/98
T 0438/98
T 0556/98
T 0621/98
T 0840/98
T 0695/99
T 0966/99
T 0780/00
T 0896/00
T 0922/00
T 1048/00
T 1169/00
T 0179/01
T 0292/01
T 0475/01
T 1288/01
T 0063/02
T 0302/02
T 0596/02
T 0764/02
T 0956/02
T 1212/02
T 0120/03
T 0315/03
T 0566/03
T 0741/03
T 0877/03
T 0089/04
T 0256/04
T 0496/04
T 1392/04
T 0365/05
T 0774/05
T 1394/05
T 0083/06
T 0392/06
T 0678/06
T 0910/06
T 1207/06
T 1208/06
T 1706/06
T 0095/07
T 0131/07
T 0482/07
T 0520/07
T 0699/07
T 0708/07
T 0919/07
T 1357/07
T 0378/08
T 0453/08
T 0604/08
T 1168/08
T 1546/08
T 2135/08
T 0124/09
T 0150/09
T 0756/09
T 1045/09
T 0032/10
T 0614/10
T 1314/10
T 1693/10
T 2422/10
T 0577/11
T 1271/11
T 1329/11
T 1458/11
T 1713/11
T 2197/11
T 2321/11
T 2552/11
T 0443/12
T 0623/12
T 1150/12
T 1431/12
T 1654/12
T 1706/12
T 1821/12
T 1914/12
T 2036/12
T 2440/12
T 1027/13
T 1102/13
T 1233/13
T 2086/13
T 0420/14
T 1635/14
T 1668/14
T 1890/15
T 2068/15
T 2196/15
T 0421/16
T 2492/16

78 references found.

Click X to load a reference inside the current page, click on the title to open in a new page.

EPC Articles

EPO Guidelines - E General Procedural Matters

Offical Journal of the EPO

Case Law Book: III Amendments

Case Law Book: IV Divisional Applications

Case Law of the Enlarged Board

General Case Law