CLR I C 3.2.4.D Internal structure or composition of a product

In many cases the ability to recognise a technical teaching such as the internal structure or composition of a product in prior use presupposes analysis of the product embodying this technical teaching. Whether it is technically feasible to analyse a product that is available on the open market is an issue that the boards have considered on a number of occasions.

CLR I C 3.2.4.C No public prior use

In T 363/90 a machine fitted with a sheet feeder corresponding to the claimed invention had been exhibited and demonstrated at trade fairs. The board concluded that, under the circumstances, it was impossible for the skilled person to recognise – or to infer on the basis of further information – the technical features and the functions of the exhibited sheet feeder to an extent which would have enabled him to copy its design, let alone develop it further.

Pages

Subscribe to XEPC: EPC and PCT resource RSS